Encl (1) to COMDTINST 1650.2B
Station B: (one inspected boat)
Boat's Initial Evaluation:
Bravo (Restricted)
Material Condition:
13 points
Written Test:
4 points
Underway Exercise:
9 points
PPE:
9 points
Training:
8 points
Total unit score:
43 points
This unit does not qualify for the Sumner I. Kimball Award. While's the inspected boat's initial
assessment was "Bravo (Restricted), unit's final score did not meet the 90% requirement (45 of 50
possible points).
Station C: (two boats attached, one ready boat required)
Ready Boat Initial Evaluation:
Bravo
Stand-By Boat Initial Evaluation:
Charlie
Material Condition:
Boat One: 15 points
Boat Two: 9 points
Total Material Condition:
12 points
Written Test:
4 points
Underway Exercise:
9 points
PPE:
10 points
Training:
10 points
Total unit score:
45 points
This unit qualifies for the Sumner I. Kimball Award. Ready boat's initial assessment was "Bravo" and
minimum point requirement was achieved.
Station D: (four boats, two ready boats required)
Ready Boat One Initial Evaluation:
Bravo
Ready Boat Two Initial Evaluation:
Charlie
Stand-By Boat Three Initial Evaluation: Charlie
Stand-By Boat Four Initial Evaluation: Bravo (Restricted)
Material Condition:
Boat One:
15 points
Boat Two:
11 points
Boat Three:
10 points
Boat Four:
13 points
Total Material Condition:
12 points
Written Test:
4 points
Underway Exercise:
9 points
PPE:
10 points
Training:
10 points
Total unit score:
45 points
This unit does not qualify for the Sumner I. Kimball Award. While the unit met the minimum score required to
receive the award, ready boat two's initial assessment was "Charlie."
5